This is the same design as used in 1879 on J1626-J1630/P1822-P1827.
It was also part of a goloid set. To view Barber's set which included this design, click here.
Examples were struck as follows:
Silver or Goloid J1651/P1851 with about a dozen known. It would be interesting to test these to see if any are actually Goloid.
Copper J1652/P1852 with slightly over a dozen known.
Aluminum J1653/P1853 with the following 4 confirmed including the one illustrated below.
1) Lohr, Polis-B/M 6/91, Heritage 1/03, Simpson collection - PCGS67
2) Stacks 6/88, Superior 9/88, Heritage 9/03, Cassel-Heritage 8/15 ANA, Saul Teichman - PCGS66
3) Maris, Garrett, JHU, Garrett II-B/R 3/80, Superior 10/90, Superior 8/91, Heritage 3/03, 5/03 as PCGS64, 7/03 as NGC65, 11/03 as NGC65, 8/04, 12/9/04, 12/28/04, 1/05, 3/05, 5/05 - PCGS64, illustrated below
4) Boosel-RARCOA 5/72, Sieck 81 ANA, Heritage 6/87, Superior 10/92, Heritage 99 FUN - PCGS63
Photo courtesy of Saul Teichman and Heritage.